I’ve never been a diehard fan of waterproof mascara because removing it can be very tricky. After the removal process (yes it is a process), I’m left with a burning sensation or red, irritated eyes from the constant rubbing and pulling. What’s even worse? Finding a few eyelashes on your fingertips and all you want to do is scream. Who can deal after that?
I don’t totally dislike waterproof mascara. I just prefer to not use it as much because of the removal process but not anymore. You’ll find out why as you continue to read.
Here are some of the great things we all love about waterproof mascara:
less to no smudging (depending on the brand)
lush, thick eyelashes
adds volume
worth it for hitting the pool or super sweaty days
Now here are things we generally dislike about the waterproof mascara removal process:
irritates the eyes
may accidentally remove eyelashes
develop a burning sensation
can cause an eye infection. YIKES!
Now, I’ve come across all sorts of methods to remove waterproof mascara. Here are 3 common methods below.
Method #1: The Facial Cleanser
A facial cleanser is one of the most easiest and laziest ways to remove waterproof mascara.
Positives
Easy method
convenient
Negatives
can dry out lashes
can be too harsh for eyes and surrounding skin
can leave your eyes stinging
Method #2: Vaseline aka Petroleum Jelly
This is actually a great method and a method I’ve used in the past.
Positives
cheaper alternative
fast and effective
lash conditioner
Negatives
too greasy
linked to being a carcinogen (I’m no scientist so, read this article if you have mixed feelings on PJ- Does Petroleum Jelly Cause Cancer?)
Method #3: Olive Oil
Olive oil is an all-natural solution and can be used as a good quality mascara remover.
Positives
Organic so it’s good for the environment
it’s gentle
great for people with sensitive skin
Negatives
Often times leaves a “gooey” feeling around the eyes (I personally hate that!)
So, what’s my #1 recommendation to remove waterproof mascara effectively?
Answer: Finding an excellent waterproof eye makeup remover. In fact, I found one!
My ultra favorite remover is Sonia Kashuk “Remove” Eye Makeup Remover ($9.99). It’s one of the most effective waterproof mascara remover I’ve come across in a long time and I’ve tried a lot. It’s gentle and can easily remove all traces of the waterproof mascara with ease. It’s perfect for people with sensitive skin too!
I love to use Yves Rocher makeup remover-it has two layers-oil one and remover one. It has to be shaken properly to mix both layers but I never had better makeup/waterproof mascara remover. It’s gentle to eyes too!
I love Motives Waterproof Mascara ($11.50). It does a great job, is soft on the eyes, and is oil free! Love the tip about letting the mascara soften first! I’ll try that next time!
We use cookies to customize content and advertising and to ensure that we give you the best experience on our website. If you continue to use this site we will assume that you are happy with our terms. :) Ok
Privacy & Cookies Policy
Privacy Overview
This website uses cookies to improve your experience while you navigate through the website. Out of these, the cookies that are categorized as necessary are stored on your browser as they are essential for the working of basic functionalities of the ...
Necessary cookies are absolutely essential for the website to function properly. This category only includes cookies that ensures basic functionalities and security features of the website. These cookies do not store any personal information.
Any cookies that may not be particularly necessary for the website to function and is used specifically to collect user personal data via analytics, ads, other embedded contents are termed as non-necessary cookies. It is mandatory to procure user consent prior to running these cookies on your website.
I love to use Yves Rocher makeup remover-it has two layers-oil one and remover one. It has to be shaken properly to mix both layers but I never had better makeup/waterproof mascara remover. It’s gentle to eyes too!
I love Motives Waterproof Mascara ($11.50). It does a great job, is soft on the eyes, and is oil free! Love the tip about letting the mascara soften first! I’ll try that next time!